CHAPTER IX: Concerning a
Complex
All of these books, history and fiction, drop into the American mind
during its early springtime the seed of antagonism, establish in fact an
anti-English "complex." It is as pretty a case of complex on the wholesale
as could well be found by either historian or psychologist. It is not so
violent as the complex which has been planted in the German people by
forty years of very adroitly and carefully planned training: they were
taught to distrust and hate everybody and to consider themselves so
superior to anybody that their sacred duty as they saw it in 1914 was to
enslave the world in order to force upon the world the priceless benefits of
their Kultur. Under the shock of war that complex dilated into a form of
real hysteria or insanity. Our anti-English com- plex is fortunately milder
than that; but none the less does it savor slightly, as any nerve specialist or
psychological doctor would tell you---it savors slightly of hysteria, that
hundreds of thousands of American men and women of every grade of
education and ignorance should automatically exclaim whenever the right
button is pressed, "England is a land-grabber," and "What has England
done in the War?"
The word complex has been in our dictionary for a long while. This
familiar adjective has been made by certain scientific people into a noun,
and for brevity and convenience employed to denote something that
almost all of us harbor in some form or other. These complexes, these
lumps of ideas or impressions that match each other, that are of the same
pattern, and that are also invariably tinctured with either a pleasurable or
painful emotion, lie buried in our minds, unthought-of but alive, and lurk
always ready to set up a ferment, whenever some new thing from outside
that matches them enters the mind and hence starts them off. The
"suppressed complex" I need not describe, as our English complex is by
no means suppressed. Known to us all, probably, is the political complex.
Year after year we have been excited about elections and candidates and
policies, preferring one party to the other. If this preference has been very
A STRAIGHT DEAL
marked, or even violent, you know how disinclined we are to give credit
to the other party for any act or policy, no matter how excellent in itself,
which, had our own party been its sponsor, we should have been heart and
soul for. You know how easily we forget the good deeds of the opposite
party and how easily we remember its bad deeds. That's a good simple
ordinary example of a complex. Its workings can be discerned in the
experience of us all. In our present discussion it is very much to the point.
Established in the soft young minds of our school boys and girls by a
series of reiterated statements about the tyranny and hostility of England
towards us in the Revolution, statements which they have to remember
and master by study from day to day, tinctured by the anxiety about the
examination ahead, when the students must know them or fail, these
incidents of school work being also tinctured by another emotion, that of
patriotism, enthusiasm for Washington, for the Declaration of
Independence, for Valley Forge--thus established in the regular way of all
complexes, this anti-English complex is fed and watered by what we learn
of the War of 1812, by what we learn of the Civil War of 1861, and by
many lesser events in our history thus far. And just as a Republican will
admit nothing good of a Democrat and a Democrat nothing good of a
Republican because of the political complex, so does the great--the vast--
majority of Americans automatically and easily remember everything
against England and forget everything in her favor. Just try it any day you
like. Ask any average American you are sitting next to in a train what he
knows about England; and if he does remember anything and can tell it to
you, it will be unfavorable nine times in ten. The mere word "England"
starts his complex off, and out comes every fact it has seized that matches
his school-implanted prejudice, just as it has rejected every fact that does
not match it. There is absolutely no other way to explain the American
habit of speaking ill of England and well of France. Several times in the
past, France has been flagrantly hostile to us. But there was Lafayette,
there was Rochambeau, and the great service France did us then against
England. Hence from our school histories we have a pro-French complex.
Under its workings we automatically remember every good turn France
has done us and automatically forget the evil turns. Again try the
A STRAIGHT DEAL
experiment yourself. How many Americans do you think that you will find
who can recall, or who even know when you recall to them the insolent
and meddlesome Citizen Genet, envoy of the French Republic, and how
Washington requested his recall? Or the French privateers that a little later,
about 1797-98, preyed upon our commerce? And the hatred of France
which many Americans felt and expressed at that time? How many
remember that the King of France, directly our Revolution was over, was
more hostile to us than England?
A STRAIGHT DEAL