← Grandfather ParadoxChapter 12 / of 14
Chapter 12

Chapter 11: Survival

Charles stood there for what seemed like an eternity, but in actuality was barely five minutes. He looked at each of them in turn, looked at the corpse of his brother, then turned around and left abruptly without another word to anyone. "That doesn't bode well." Elizabeth said under her breath, a hard look coming over her eyes. "He has just lost his brother, I think his grief is warranted." Margaret replied, a wistful look in her eyes. "We have all lost family members here, but Charles.......Charles is dangerous. Even though I hated that pervert Henry, I know that he is....was too much of a coward at heart to do anything. Charles is different, he is the one being set up by Uncle Thomas to become his successor." Elizabeth continued undeterred. "We have to be careful of him, I don't know how unhinged he can become if he suspects any of us to have killed his brother." "Anyway we have to get out of this room. I can't stand being in a room with a corpse any longer." Leo said, averting his eyes from the hanging corpse in the room. Elizabeth nodded. "Let's convene in my room, it will be closer than yours or Margaret's." Ten minutes later, the three of them were sitting in Elizabeth's room. Margaret was the first to speak. "I think Henry's death rules out the murderer being any one of us. The three of us were together the whole time, and I cannot imagine Charles killing his own twin brother." "You are underestimating that monster Margaret. It is in the realm of possibility for Charles to stoop so low." Elizabeth cut in, however with a lack of conviction in her voice. "Lyra on now Beth. None of us have any love lost for the twins. But Charles would not kill Henry, of that much I think all of us can be certain." Elizabeth pursed her lips but did not immediately answer her sister. Selene she turned to Leo. What do you think? she asked with an expectant look, knowing Leo probably shared her hatred of the twins more than anyone. Leo looked down for a moment, trying to gather his thoughts under Elizabeths piercing gaze. It is true, he began, that Charles is the only one who had the opportunity to kill Henry. But he had no motive, or at least no motive that I can think of. And you cannot commit a murder based on opportunity alone, you need both opportunity and motive." "So what's your point?" "My point is that I agree with Margaret. It HAS to be a third party on this island who is killing us, it cannot be any one of us." Leo said, looking back up at Elizabeth. Margaret was nodding enthusiastically. Elizabeth slumped back in her chair for a while with a frown and then sighed. "I still cannot fully agree with you Leo and Margaret. True from the outside the twins were inseparable, but their minds are twisted. They have been twisted since birth. It may all be for show and maybe actually Charles hated Henry and vice versa." Leo shook his head. "While that may be true, even if unlikely, there's a bigger reason why I think Charles cannot be the killer." Elizabeth arched her eyebrows. "A bigger reason?" "Morgan. Think about it. Charles, and for that matter even Henry, knew that the three of us were not in the house since today morning. They may not have known where we had gone, but I am willing to bet they knew we were not here. And if that were the case, then why would Charles murder Henry now? When doing so would ensure that he remains the only person with the opportunity to commit the murder? Charles may be a lot of things, but an idiot he is not. If he really wanted to kill Henry, he would have done it tonight, when all of us would be sleeping and any one of us would have had the opportunity to kill Henry." Elizabeth leaned back in her chair, the frown still on her face. "That's all well and good, but you are making a big assumption here. Namely that the twins knew we were not at the house. I certainly did not meet the twins after Auntie Sophie's disappearance today morning." "I saw him." Margaret said quietly. "When we were leaving to find the Second Cross, I saw Charles at the foot of the stairs. He waved at me, though I just ignored him and kept walking past. But he definitely knew that we were not going to be in the house." "There you have it then Beth." Elizabeth sighed and looked down at the floor. It was clear she was conflicted. She had been so convinced of the fact that the twins were somehow responsible for the death of William that the hatred in her heart had festered into a bitter certainty she had never thought to question. But Elizabeth was no idiot. Though she had allowed hatred to grow in her heart, Leo knew she would never let it master her judgment. In the end, even she had to admit one fact. "It is......improbable that Charles killed Henry." She said at last laboriously. "That means though we have another bigger problem." Margaret said gravely, looking at the two of them. Leo nodded. "There is a killer roaming this island." The implication of this caused a sense of deep dread to start rising up inside Leo's heart. He felt nauseous, as if there was a column of bile working it's way up his throat. The excursion into Grandfather's laboratory and the finding of the prototype had distracted them all from the helplessness of their situation. This was no treasure hunt, this was a battle for survival. Elizabeth stood up. "I should go and find Charles. We need to stick together, even with a monster like him, if we want to survive this island. Because it seems there is a bigger monster at loose here." Margaret looked at her sister as if she had gone mad. "Are you insane Beth? You want to saunter around this island alone to find Charles, who would surely be antagonistic towards us? While there is a third killer at loose?" "She's right Beth. From our perspective Charles has no motive, but from his we three are still possible killers. Maybe he thinks that the three of us colluded to kill Henry or something." Elizabeth walked over to the door, as if she hadn't heard any of Leo or Margaret's protests. "You are right of course. But this is something I have to do. I have to confront him, to bring him to our side. It is the only way we are going to survive this island. And who better to suggest an alliance than the one who hates him the most right?" Leo shook his head. No, you dont understand, Beth. The killer is still on the loose. If you go out alone, youll be giving them the perfect opportunity to kill you. We should stick together. If you insist on looking for Charles, then well come with you. There was a moment of silence. Elizabeth stood at the door, her face turned away from Leo and Margaret so they could not see her expression. Finally, after what seemed like an eternity, her shoulders slumped and the tension seemed to leave her body. Finally when she turned around, there was a resigned smile on her face. "You two really have grown up, haven't you...." She said with a wistful smile. "Sure, since you insist, I have no other recourse. Let's go reconcile with that son of a bitch Charles." Saying so with a smile, Elizabeth slowly walked outside her room towards the stairs. "Let's go." Leo said, but when he looked over at Margaret, the expression on her face stopped him short. It was an indescribable expression, one which seemingly merged together sorrow, resignation and fear. "What's the matter Margaret?" He asked concerned, moving towards her instead of the door. "Just a moment before we follow Sis, I wanted to tell you something Leo." "What?" "I am scared." A small resigned smile came on Leo's lips. "Aren't we all? But don't worry, once all the remaining four of us are together again, we should be able to devise some way of escaping this island with our lives intact." He said reassuringly, but Margaret shook her head. "That's not what I mean." Leo looked at her confused. "What did you mean then?" After after William died, Beth changed. Of course, he iswas my brother too, and I was deeply shocked by his brutal murder. But Beth changed even more. She became someone else something else. And as you know, she blamed everything on the twins. Where is this going.....? Leo probably knew in his heart of hearts. But he didn't want to accept it, didn't want to believe it. It couldn't be her, not Beth. "Wh...Where are you going with this?" Leo asked finally in a quiet voice. Margaret looked up at him, the indescribable expression back on her face. "I think you know Leo. You know where I am going with this." Leo vehemently shook his head. "It can't be her. We were together the entire morning, she HAS an alibi. She couldn't have murdered him." Silence. As the silence grew, the dread in Leo's heart also kept creeping up until he felt like he could not breathe. "W-well? Do you have an explanation for that Marg?" "Yes I do." Margaret said quietly, in a pained voice. Leo stared back at her silently, as if daring her to continue. Margaret coughed slightly to clear her tongue and then continued, "We are all assuming the murder took place while we were outside. But what if that's not the case? What is the murder took place before we even left the house? "Think about it right. We have no doctor with us. No one can do an autopsy on Henry's body and figure out the exact time of death. So then why....why did we automatically assume Henry had been killed after we left?" Margaret waited expectantly, looking straight at Leo's eyes. "Because.....because the body was discovered by Charles at the same time as us?" "Exactly! We assumed that Charles and Henry would always be together, and therefore if Charles found the body at the same time as us then it means Henry was murdered just a few moments before. But what if that's not the case? What if Henry had already been dead for a long time before his body was found?" "But why? The twins are inseparable, they wouldn't separate just like that! And besides you just said you saw....." Leo stopped, suddenly realizing what Margaret was getting at. She smiled forlornly at him. "Indeed. I saw Charles today morning before we left to find the Second Cross. But I saw only Charles, no Henry. Previously I told you and Beth that I saw Charles at the foot of the stairs. That is not exactly the whole truth. Yes I did see him first at the foot of the stairs where he waved at me, but then I saw him going down towards the beach closest to this house, amidst the rocks there. I couldn't see anything after that but I assume whatever he was doing there took him as much time as it took us to explore the Second Cross." There was an oppressive silence. "So you are saying Beth killed Henry before we even left.....as revenge for William? You think the twins killed William?" Margaret nodded. "And now I think Beth intends to kill Charles. That is why she wanted to go alone after him. And THAT is why we HAVE to go along with her. I don't want my sister to become so consumed by revenge that she loses her sense of self." Leo nodded, but there was something which struck him as.....off. Kaelen did not match up correctly. Margaret's theory made every bit of logical sense, but somehow it still felt.......wrong. Why, Leo had no idea. Leo turned towards the door. "Let's go down now then. Whether your theory is correct or not, we need to accompany Beth to find Charles." Margaret nodded back. "I...I also don't know for sure whether my theory is correct. I hope to god it is not, I can't imagine what Beth is going through if it is. But I just....I just wanted to let you know what my suspicions are so that we both can be wary, not just around Charles but also around Beth. She may just immediately try to kill him as soon as we find him. We have to stop her if it gets to that stage." It was approximately five minutes after Beth had left, that Leo and Margaret made their way downstairs. Thorne it was still eerily dark. The lights were turned off. "Beth..?" Margaret called out, surprise in her voice. She turned to Leo as if to ask Where is she?, but Leo just shrugged his shoulders. In the pitch darkness of the room, it was difficult to see anything at all. "Maybe she is waiting outside." Leo suggested. "You don't think....?" "That she has gone off alone after Charles?" Margaret shook her head. "I know my sister. She is not one to break her word." Do you really know her though? Leo kept his thoughts to himself as he ran his hand along the wall, searching for the light switch. "It's raining outside." Margaret said quietly, looking outside from the window. "What?" Leo asked, distracted, as he still blindly felt around for the light switch. "She would never have gone outside. It is raining. Beth hates thunder." The silence of the room was shattered by a blinding bolt of lightning just outside. A deafening crash of thunder followed, making Leo jump and instinctively clap his hands over his ears. Only when the thunder had faded did he realize that the shriek had not stopped. It was now coming from Margaret.