Chapter 12: The First Cross
Leo frantically looked around for Margaret in the darkness, finally finding her almost crouched near a chair.
"What's the matter Marg?" He rushed towards her. Margaret was on her knees, trembling, her eyes fixed on the chair.
The chair was not empty.
Leo looked over where her horrified eyes were pointing, and he stumbled back himself.
Elizabeth sat in the chair. She appeared to be sleeping, the moonlight streaming through the window on her pale face. Indeed Leo would have accepted she were sleeping except for one small detail.
The knife sticking out in her throat. The blood pooling beneath the chair.
Leo tried screaming, but his voice would not come out. It felt as if someone was choking him.
No no no no no no. Elizabeth was just alive.....she was JUST alive....
His brain refused to process it, he stared blankly at Elizabeth's corpse, his mouth open like a fish trying to breathe.
So when the blow came to the back of his head, Leo didn't try to fight against the darkness of unconsciousness swallowing him up. He embraced it, gratefully closing his eyes, gratefully escaping from the horror of the present.
Leo woke to the smell of the sea.
He lay there on the cold, clammy ground, eyes closed, trying to convince himself that it was a dream. That if he kept his eyes shut for long enough, he would find himself back at home with his mother waking him up.
Eventually though he had to open his eyes and look around.
He was in what seemed to be a jail cell inside a cave. Margaret was lying prone besides him, also unconscious. The inside of the cell was dark, but there was some light streaming in from the entrance, which seemed to have a lantern on the wall, which allowed Leo to see the figure sitting in a chair in front of the jail cell.
"So Elizabeth was right. You are the killer, Charles!"
Charles looked up. His eyes were bloodshot, and his face looked like he had aged a decade.
"Playing dumb till the end little Leo?" Charles asked with a rasp. "Tell me why did you do it? Why did you kill Henry? Or was that Margaret?"
"What? We didn't kill Henry - you did!"
Charles threw his head back and laughed. It was a terrible sound, like the cry of a seagull.
"Don't play smart with me you fucking murderer." He sneered at Leo. "You two are the only people on this island besides me, you are the only person who could have killed everyone."
"From where we're standing, you're the only other person on this island. So by that logic, it was you."
Charles was silent for a bit, looking down. "The only person I....we killed was your mother Leo."
He was lunging before he knew it. His fist flew out, through the cells of the window and caught Charles right in his eye, knocking him backwards with force enough to smash him against the other wall of the cave.
"What did you say?" Leo asked quietly, his body still burning with rage.
"It was an accident! Ok a fucking accident! We wanted the gold, Henry and me. Aunt Sophie knew where it was! We confronted her and......and she slipped and fell into the ocean. We are not......I am not a cold blooded murderer like you!" Charles spat out. He rose up slowly, a gash going over his right eye bleeding on the floor.
"You killed Henry Leo. I will watch you die for that. Both you and Margaret." He said.
"No one is buying your horseshit story Charles. You killed everyone. You always hated everyone, you always thought you were better than us all. And this is the consequence of that huh? You have become a crazy psycho killer? Let me out Charles, face me like a man you sniveling coward!" Leo had lost all reason, banging his head against the jail cell.
Charles stood up, smirking. "You are going to die in there Leo. And don't try to twist facts. Aunt Sophie's death was an accident, but everyone you and Margaret killed was intentional. William? Elizabeth? Henry? Your own cousins? Margaret's blood siblings? And then you have the audacity to say something is wrong WITH ME?"
Charles started going towards the cave exit, looking back one final time, "Enjoy starving to death murderers." Saying so he left, taking the lantern along with him, plunging Leo back to pitch black darkness.
"Lyra back here! Charles!! CHARLES!" Leo shouted until his voice broke, his fist rattling the bars.
There was a scream. Leo jerked up. The scream had come from Charles, right outside the cave! Leo could not see what was happening but the scream had been unmistakable.
"Charles?" Leo called out quietly, unsure.
There was no response.
"Charles??" Leo called out once more, with more insistence.
Still nothing.
Then Leo heard footsteps outside the cave. Footsteps which seemed to be dragging something. Or someone.
The body of Charles was thrown unceremoniously into the cave, hitting the same wall where he had slumped over moments earlier. And then another figure walked into the cave, holding the lantern.
And then for the second time that night, Leo wondered whether he was in some extended nightmare.
For the figure in front of him was his own grandfather.