← Grandfather ParadoxChapter 14 / of 14
Chapter 14

Chapter 13: Grandfather Kaelen [The End]

Throughout his life Leo had seen his grandfather only twice. Once when he was a small child and his mother had invited him to his birthday party. Leo remembered little about that meeting, the details were all fuzzy in his head. The second time was during his funeral, when Leo observed the serene body of his grandfather put down into the ground. The body. Yes Leo had seen the funeral. He had seen his grandfather's body be lowered into the grave. Ergo this man standing in front of his could not be his grandfather. "Who are you? Why do you look like Grandfather?" Leo asked, trying to keep his voice steady. From the corner of his eyes he could see that Margaret was still unconscious at the corner of the jail cell. The old man pretending to be his Grandfather looked towards him steadily. There was something familiar about his face. Of course Leo knew what his Grandfather looked like, he had seen numerous photos of him. But this was the one time he saw him alive, and it ignited some strong deja vu in him. Kaelen about the face stirred something deeper than simple recognition. The resemblance felt more intimate than it had any right to. "Good." The man rasped nodding. "You are calm enough to ask questions. And to answer you Leo, I look like your grandfather because I AM your grandfather." "Impossible. Grandfather is dead. I attended his funeral myself." Leo said quietly. The old man nodded. "Yes you are right of course. I am dead. There is no doubt about that fact. And yet I stand before you. There is also no doubt about that fact. How can we reconcile these two paradoxical statements?" He slowly walked forward and sat down on the chair where Charles was sitting a few moments ago, just in front of the jail cell. Charles, whose corpse still lay slumped against the far wall. "Have you heard of the Grandfather Kaelen Leo?" Leo stood silently for a while, and then nodded. The old man took this as his cue to continue, "Of course it is one of the most famous paradoxes regarding time travel. What if you go back in time and kill your own grandfather? Then that would mean that your father would not be born, and then you yourself would not be born, and thus you would not exist for killing your grandfather. A true paradox which confirmed for many people that time travel cannot exist, because how would the world react to this scenario?" He stopped and looked at Leo's face. The only sound was the soft lapping of the sea outside and the crackle of flames within the lantern. "How would it react?" Leo asked quietly, sensing that he was waiting for an answer. The old man sighed and leaned back in his chair. "It would react by replacement. The killer would take over the concept of the grandfather. In other words the killer himself would BECOME the grandfather. And do you know what that means? The killer and the grandfather would be stuck in a never-ending circle. A loop. A punishment." His voice grew more and more agitated. "The killer kills the grandfather. The killer is forced to become the grandfather. The killer gives birth to the father. The father gives birth to the grandson. And eventually the grandson comes back and kills the original killer. That is the punishment for triggering the Grandfather Kaelen." Here the old man looked at Leo once more, and with a growing dread Leo realized why the face seemed so familiar. He had seen it before. Not just in Grandfather's funeral. But in his own mirror. "No. No no no no no. That cannot be." Leo staggered backward. The world seemed to spin around him. Grandfather -- for it could be no one else -- looked at him sadly. "But yes it is Leo. You are me. I am you. Herbert Cooper is the same person as Leo Cooper, connected by an inescapable time loop." "So what? You killed everyone? I killed everyone??" Grandfather nodded sadly. "Why? For heaven's sake why??" "Because that is what the time loop demands. Neither I nor you when you come to this point, can escape it. Why did I kill everyone in the original timeline? I am afraid no one has that answer now Leo. But the reason I killed everyone is because at one time I WAS in the same spot where you are right now, listening to someone claiming to be my grandfather saying things which seemed impossible. Impossible and ghastly. So I know exactly how you feel. That's not just to reassure you. I literally know EXACTLY how you feel because I felt the same way at one time." "No that doesn't make any sense. That doesn't make any fucking sense! I will break the loop, I will go back home! How can I become you? You are in the past!" Leo was almost shouting hysterically now. Grandfather stood up. "I am afraid that is not possible Leo. The island won't let you go back home. Indeed once we are done and you kill me, the island will wipe your memories and deposit you in 1948." "Wait what? I kill you?" "Yes. After all my body has to wash up on shore dead. Don't you remember? I died ten years back according to your timeline. After you kill me, you have to throw my body in the water and it will come back to shore ten years ago as per you." "Wait wait wait. So for you, the time is ten years ago?" "The time for this entire island boy, is ten years ago. It is 2010 here currently, but I know you came from 2020. After all so did I. My youth was in 2020. But after you kill me and throw me in the water, the beginning of your adulthood would be in 1948." "No. I cannot kill you. I cannot!" "You can. You HAVE to. Time itself demands it." Leo shook his head defiantly. "NO. I WILL break the loop! That's how we can break the loop right? I refuse to kill you?" Grandfather shook his head sadly. "You know, you were looking for the time machine right? My time machine? Did you find it?" Leo started once at the sudden change of subject then shook his head. Grandfather nodded. "Of course.....of course. You see, that is one of the ways we can see if the loop is different this time. If there is something that happened or something you did that I don't remember, then maybe there is some chance of the loop not repeating. But alas that is not the case. You want to know where my time machine is?" He spreads his arms theatrically. "This. This entire island is my time machine. Time on this island flows differently at every place. The western coast and the eastern coast run on different times. And yet when you leave this island, it will cease to be a time machine until you find it here back again in the 2000s. You see, I did not invent time travel, I discovered it. Someone, somewhere in time, had already or will already build this island as their time machine, and I found it myself." Here he stopped, and then he looked over at the prone Margaret. Panic rose in Leo as he slowly stepped between them. "No." He whispered quietly. Grandfather nodded reassuringly. "No indeed. Margaret is also going to be a survivor of this island Leo. In fact she is going to be more than that, she is your grandmother and your wife." "What? She is my cousin!" Leo recoiled backwards in shock and revulsion. Grandfather looked at him sadly. "Yes, yes indeed she is. But neither of you will have any memories when you leave this island. You will just be two people with no memories recovered from the same boat. That bonds people you know? Seeing people in a similar situation to them? Of course eventually, near the end of both of your lives, your memories will return. Like they have for me." He taps his head. "But for Marg, her memories will return before yours. And she.....she will not be able to handle the ugly truth. She will......will commit suicide." There is an indescribable heaviness and dread in Grandfather's voice. "Why are you telling me this? I won't remember anything anyway right? Until it is too late to do anything." Leo asked quietly. Grandfather smiled sadly. "Yes indeed. But I was not able to talk to anyone about this you know. For years and years now I have carried a terrible secret, walked towards a terrible goal without even knowing it. And I got my memories after Margaret died, so the one person who I had to support me all those years was also gone. I am just venting you can say. Like my Grandfather did to me." There was an oppressive silence. "So what happens now?" Leo asked. Grandfather walked over to the jail cell, and used a key to open the door. "Well two things. First I take all the corpses and put them in chairs in the manor. And then you kill me and throw me in the water. And then I can no longer provide you any advice. Or rather it won't help you if I do provide any advice, because you will not remember anything. Shall we get to it then, myself?" It took two hours to gather all the corpses and move them to the manor. Leo recoiled in horror as he saw his mother's corpse was among them as well. She looked peaceful, like she was sleeping, with no wounds visible on her body, the only corpse like that. Grandfather explained it is because she died through drowning. "How did you......did you recover her body?" Leo asked, staring at the sky, not able to look at all the corpses lined up there. "I....I knew. I had experienced it myself as you, you know. I knew approximately where she would be pushed off the cliff, so I had mechanisms in place to retrieve her corpse." Retrieve her corpse. Not save her life, but retrieve her corpse. "I see you are angry with me Leo. As I told you, there is no going against time. I could not save her, even if I wanted to." "Speaking like that about your mother who is also your daughter is just monstrous 'Grandfather'." Leo said, no hint of respect in his voice. "Indeed. And yet you will turn into this monstrous Grandfather one day yourself Leo." After all the corpses were moved and set up in chairs on the manor, Leo looked back at his grandfather. "When we arrived the corpses were rotten." He said. "Yes, because you guys will arrive ten years from now. I place these corpses in 2010, when I am going to be killed by you." Leo did not say anything. Grandfather had seemed to accept wholly that Leo would be killing him after this, but Leo knew that he wasn't a murderer. He couldn't kill anyone! You will kill all of these people. William. Elizabeth. Henry. Charles. Leo grimaced. If what Grandfather was saying was true, and it seemed to be completely true at this point, then he was indeed a murderer. Or he would turn into one. A cold blooded murderer who doesn't think twice before killing his own family members. After all the corpses had been placed, Leo returned to the jail cell and carried Margaret on his shoulder out towards the beach on the western coast. Grandfather said that this was the fourth cross, the final part of his journey in inventing, or rather discovering, the time machine. The incident which brought back all of his memories. Once there, Leo gently lowered Margaret on a nearby rock. He still felt somewhat nauseous staring at her, remembering Grandfather's words about how he will marry her and then she will commit suicide when she gets to know. An unavoidable tragedy. Like everything else over here. In the last two hours, Leo had slowly but surely convinced himself of what needed to be done. It surprised him, he didn't know he had that much steel in him, that he could be so cold blooded. But seeing Grandfather make preparations for discovery ten years later had an air of finality in it. It made the situation seem normal. Leo knew part of it was intentional on his Grandfather's part. And then finally it was time. Grandfather led Leo to the beach and then turned towards him. "Remember this, Leo." His voice was quiet, unhurried, the voice of a man who had already made his peace. "The moment you push me into the water, you will forget everything. Every face, every name, every year of your life before this day - gone. That is your singularity. The moment you stop being Leo and become Herbert Cooper." He paused, letting the weight of it settle. "Your memories will return eventually. But not until Margaret dies." Leo said nothing. There was nothing to say. "You won't remember this conversation. I know that. I've always known that." Kaelen shifted in the old man's expression not regret exactly, but something adjacent to it. "But when it all comes back to you, I want you to remember what I did today. Not the explanation. Not the reasons. What I did. Time will show you the rest, but you deserve to walk into it knowing the shape of things." He smiled then. In all the years Leo had known him, across every memory he was about to lose, he had never once seen his grandfather smile. Not like this. Not as if he meant it. Not as if he were finally letting go of a burden that had been eating away at him. A burden he was about to pass onto Leo. Grandfather spread his arms and closed his eyes. "Lyra on Leo. Do it now." Leo gritted his teeth. Could he do it? But something guided him, something pushed him forward. Screaming in anger, in pain, in confusion Leo ran forward, stabbing his knife through Grandfather's heart. The last expression on the old man's face was relief. Moving a corpse was harder than Leo had expected. He dragged his Grandfather down toward the beach by the legs, slow and heavy, the body leaving a trail in the wet sand. When he finally reached the water he let the tide do the rest. The corpse floated for a moment, then the sea took him. Leo turned back. He had minutes, maybe less. Margaret was still slumped against the rock. He crossed to her and sank down beside her. His eyes turned heavy. Leo looked around desperately, taking in the island for the last time for a long time. He knew once he fell asleep, Leo Cooper would be dead and Herbert Cooper would be born. He wanted to enjoy the last few moments of his life as Leo Cooper. In the distance a seagull cried out as Leo let slumber wash over him. THE END